A
New
Aristocracy
Yale
Law
School
Commencement
Address,
May
2015
*
Daniel
Markovits
Thanks,
Robert,
for
that
introduction;
and
thank
you
enormously
to
the
Yale
Law
School
class
of
2015
for
inviting
me
to
speak
here.
It’s
been
a
pleasure
to
teach
you;
and
it’s
a
privilege
to
address
you
now.
Countless
conversations
with
you
have
made
vivid
that
although
this
is
a
marvelous
occasion,
your
mood
is
not
triumphalist.
You’ve
seemed
to
me
not
simply
celebratory,
but
also
contemplative.
I’ll
therefore
take
this
opportunity—this
point
of
inflection
in
your
lives—
to
offer
a
diagnosis
of
your
(and
our
collective)
condition,
not
to
propose
a
cure
but,
more
modestly,
in
the
hope
that
it
shines
a
new
light
on
your
own
introspection.
Now,
the
Dean
has
just
observed,
that
you
are
“by
acclimation
the
finest
new
law
graduates
in
the
world.”
I
don’t
rehearse
this
praise
just
as
a
bromide,
to
set
a
mood
and
swell
a
speech’s
emotional
progress.
Rather,
I’ll
take
the
fact
of
your
excellence
as
my
starting
point
today
and
then
recover
its
causes
and
pursue
its
consequences.
Some
of
these
are
bright
and
happy;
others
lower
more
darkly,
both
over
the
broader
world
and
over
your
distinctive
futures.
It
will
be
the
task
of
your
*
Written
to
be
spoken
and
therefore
without
citations.
POSTED:
May 18, 2015
2
generation
to
disperse
these
clouds
and
to
reclaim
the
sunshine,
including
for
yourselves.
When
I
say
that
you
are
the
country’s
best
new
lawyers,
I
assert
a
concrete,
determinate,
and
determinable
fact;
and
a
fact
whose
demonstration
has
dominated
a
large
portion
of
your
lives
for
a
very
long
time.
Consider
how
you
got
to
Yale.
In
the
Autumn
of
2011
perhaps
75,000
candidates
applied
to
American
law
schools.
Perhaps
3000
of
these
applied
to
Yale
Law
School.
The
law
school
takes
admissions
very
seriously—three
faculty
members
independently
evaluate
each
file—
and
following
this
process,
Yale
admitted
about
8
percent
of
JD
applicants.
Our
LLM
program
similarly
admits
only
about
9
percent
of
those
who
apply.
Finally,
almost
9
out
of
every
10
people
whom
we
admit
eventually
enroll.
In
other
words,
you
are
sitting
here
today
because
you
ranked
among
the
top
3/10ths
of
one
percent
of
a
massive,
meritocratic
competition;
and
one
in
which
all
the
competitors
conspicuously
agree
about
which
is
the
biggest
prize.
The
admissions
competition
that
brought
you
here
wasn’t
an
aberration
or
an
isolated
moment,
moreover.
Rather,
most
of
you
(although
not
all)
came
to
the
Law
School
from
highly
selective
colleges.
Acceptance
rates
at
Harvard,
Princeton,
Stanford,
and
Yale
colleges—to
pick
some
familiar
examples—have
also
averaged
around
8
percent
in
recent
years.
And
not
all
of
you,
but
again
most,
came
to
college
from
3
highly
competitive
high
schools,
and
indeed
in
many
cases
from
highly
selective
elementary
schools,
and
even
pre-‐schools
.
So
our
admissions
process—in
all
its
patterns
of
planning
and
trimming,
its
rituals
of
stage-‐managed
self-‐presentation,
its
rhythms
of
ambition,
hope,
and
worry—was,
for
you,
a
familiar
rite.
For
your
entire
lives,
you
have
studied,
worked,
practiced,
trained
and
drilled;
and
then
you’ve
been
inspected,
and
finally—you
made
it
here,
after
all—
selected.
Nor
did
the
training
and
competition
end
when
you
arrived
here.
People,
including
me,
are
fond
of
saying—perhaps
a
little
prayerfully—
that
the
rat-‐race
ends
at
Yale
Law
School’s
door;
but
you
don’t
believe
it.
More
important,
you
act
as
if
you
don’t
believe
it;
you
do
almost
whatever
is
necessary
to
learn,
to
produce,
to
continue
to
distinguish
yourselves.
There’s
a
sense
in
which
you’re
right—or
at
least
reasonable—to
stay
in
the
rat-‐race.
You
all
know
the
list
of
plums
that
you’re
competing
for
and
you
agree
(astonishingly
widely)
which
are
sweetest.
This
intensifies
your
ongoing
competition:
the
clerkships,
executive-‐branch
posts,
public
interest
jobs,
elite
law-‐firm
partnerships,
and
professorships
that
you
overwhelmingly
most
want
all
have
hundreds
of
aspirants
for
each
opening.
4
A
pervasive,
effortful,
and
studied
competition
thus
dominates
and
even
overwhelms
virtually
every
year
of
the
first
three
decades
of
an
elite
professional’s
life.
The
competition
has
become
so
ingrained
that
it
is
hard
for
you
to
imagine
life
without
it.
But
the
competition
is
new;
a
striking
innovation
in
American
economic
and
social
life;
a
stark
departure
from
past
practice.
Even
Yale
Law
School
once
admitted
nearly
a
third
of
those
who
applied,
and
by
shockingly
casual
methods:
A
mid-‐century
graduate
recently
reported
that
he
came
here
after
Jack
Tate
(then
Dean
of
Admissions)
told
him
at
a
college
fair
(straightway,
and
on
the
basis
of
a
single
conversation)
“you’ll
get
in
if
you
apply.”
Things
began
to
change
in
the
1960s.
At
Yale
College,
President
Kingman
Brewster
opened
Yale
to
merit
over
of
birth,
saying
that
he
did
not
“intend
to
preside
over
a
finishing
school
on
Long
Island
Sound.”
Brewster
replaced
the
entire
admissions
office
at
once,
with
a
new
staff
that
increased
the
incoming
class’s
SAT
verbal
score
by
100
points
within
a
year
.
Once
the
meritocratic
genie
escaped
its
bottle,
moreover,
it
grew
inexorably
and
continues
to
grow
ever
stronger.
The
admissions
competition
at
Harvard,
Yale,
Princeton
and
Stanford
is
today
three
times
as
intense
as
it
was
just
20
years
ago.
The
competition
to
get
into
Yale
Law
School
is
four
times
as
intense
as
it
was
at
mid-‐century.
5
So
you’ve
reached
this
day
by
winning,
again
and
again,
at
an
unprecedentedly
demanding
and
single-‐minded
competition.
It
makes
sense
to
ask,
therefore,
what
victory
brings.
Some
good
and
even
wonderful
things.
Others
are
less
wonderful.
But
begin
with
the
good.
First,
you
join
a
community
suffused
with
astonishing
energy
and
talent.
This
shows
itself
in
the
ordinary,
everyday
life
of
the
school.
Your
skill
and
dedication
as
students
make
teaching
here
almost
effortless;
you
obliterate
the
line
between
pedagogy
properly-‐so-‐called
and
ordinary
communication.
Your
immense
talents
also
show
themselves
at
exceptional
moments:
for
example,
at
the
Die-‐In
Demonstration
that
you
organized
last
Winter,
in
the
wake
of
police
killings
in
Ferguson,
Missouri
and
on
Staten
Island.
You
assembled
over
500
people
and
over
30
organizations
to
concerted,
forceful,
insistently
demanding
yet
responsible
public
action,
on
short
notice
and
at
a
time
of
great
distress.
Set
aside
the
rightness
of
the
end
and
pause,
for
a
moment,
to
marvel
at
the
incredible
effort
and
talent
required
to
marshal
these
means.
Second,
your
successes
bring
you
immense
wealth
and
status.
First-‐year
associates
in
New
York,
as
you
likely
all
know,
today
earn
over
$160,000
thousand
per
year.
A
law
firm
now
exists
that
6
generates
profits
per
partner
exceeding
$5
million
annually;
and
70
firms
now
generate
more
than
$1
million
of
profits
per
partner
every
year.
These
vast
sums
are
also
new.
Elite
lawyers’
real
incomes
have
roughly
tripled
in
the
past-‐half
century,
which
is
more
than
ten
times
the
rate
of
income-‐growth
experienced
by
the
median
American.
Moreover,
this
explosion
in
elite
lawyers’
incomes
is
not
an
eccentric
or
even
isolated
phenomenon.
Instead,
it
fits
into
a
wider
pattern
of
rising
elite
labor
incomes
across
our
economy.
You
probably
know
that
the
share
of
total
national
income
going
to
the
top
one
percent
of
earners
has
roughly
doubled
in
the
past
three
decades.
But
it
is
perhaps
less
familiar
that
fully
4/5ths
of
that
increase
comes
from
rising
wages
paid
to
elite
labor
.
And
it
may
be
more
surprising
still
to
learn
that
the
top
one
percent
of
earners,
and
indeed
even
the
top
1/10
th
of
one
percent,
today
owe
fully
4/5ths
of
their
total
income
to
labor.
That
is
unprecendented
in
all
of
human
history:
American
meritocracy
has
created
a
state
of
affairs
in
which
the
richest
person
out
of
every
thousand
overwhelmingly
works
for
a
living.
This
perhaps
explains
the
otherwise
incomprehensible
measure
of
agreement
among
applicants
for
elite-‐training
about
which
plums
are
most
desirable.
Finally,
the
immense
incomes
on
offer
to
you
co-‐mingle
with
high
social
status.
The
older
hereditary
caste
order
for
centuries
imposed
a
social
taint
on
those
who
work—not
from
passion,
for
exploit,
or
as
a
calling—but
industriously,
for
wages.
But
that
stigma,
which
remained
at
mid-‐century,
has
today
been
entirely
erased.
More
directly
and
7
immediately,
elite
lawyers’
incomes,
including
when
diluted
by
sabbaticals
from
private
practice
and
into
public
service,
will
place
you
comfortably
above
the
economic
dividing
line
that
comprehensively
separates
the
rich
from
the
rest
in
an
increasingly
unequal
America.
Perhaps
most
critically,
your
lawyerly
skills
will
finance
training
your
children—through
private
schools
and
myriad
other
enrichments—to
thrive
in
the
hyper-‐competition
that
you
have
yourselves,
in
effect,
just
won.
This,
then,
is
where
things
stand.
We
have
become
a
profession
and
a
society
constituted
by
meritocracy.
Massively
intensified
and
massively
competitive
elite
training
meets
massively
inflated
economic
and
social
rewards
to
elite
work.
You,
in
virtue
of
sitting
here
today,
belong
to
the
elite—to
the
new,
superordinate
working
class.
This
structure,
whatever
its
virtues,
also
imposes
enormous
costs.
Most
obviously,
it
is
a
catastrophe
for
our
broader
society—for
the
many
(the
nearly
99
percent)
who
are
excluded
from
the
increasingly
narrow
elite.
There
is
an
irony
here.
Brewster
and
others
embraced
meritocracy
self-‐consciously
in
order
to
defeat
hereditary
privilege.
Under
the
prior
regime,
pedigree
so
dominated
university
admissions
that
the
privileged
excruciatingly
under-‐performed
once
on
campus.
At
Yale,
the
traditional
feeder
prep
schools,
which
accounted
for
perhaps
a
8
quarter
of
the
class,
were
under-represented
in
Phi
Beta
Kappa
by
a
factor
of
nearly
twenty
to
one.
William
F.
Buckley,
Jr.,
in
seeking
to
mock
meritocracy,
instead
presented
an
object-‐lesson
in
the
unfairness
that
meritocracy
sought
to
redress.
“You
will
laugh,”
he
wrote
in
attacking
Brewster’s
admissions
revolution,
“but
it
is
true
that
a
Mexican-‐American
from
El
Paso
High
with
identical
scores
on
the
achievement
test,
and
identically
ardent
recommendations
from
the
headmaster,
has
a
better
chance
of
being
admitted
to
Yale
than
Jonathan
Edwards
the
Sixteenth
from
Saint
Paul’s
School.”
Just
so
.
The
meritocrat
replies.
But
although
it
was
once
the
engine
of
American
social
mobility,
meritocracy
today
blocks
equality
of
opportunity.
The
student
bodies
at
elite
colleges
once
again
skew
massively
towards
wealth:
students
from
households
in
the
top
quarter
of
the
income
distribution
outweigh
those
from
the
bottom
quarter
by
14
to
1
and
outweigh
those
from
the
middle
two
quarters
combined
by
nearly
3
to
1.
The
skew
towards
wealth
at
the
most
elite
universities
is
almost
inconceivably
greater
still.
At
Harvard
College
and
here,
at
Yale
Law
School
(two
places
where
students
have
skillfully
and
bravely
compiled
data
that
their
Universities
suppress),
as
many
students
come
from
households
in
the
top
one
percent
as
from
the
entire
bottom
half
of
the
income
distribution.
These
facts
will
shock,
as
they
are
designed
to
do;
but
a
moment’s
clear
reflection
should
render
them
unsurprising
and
even
inevitable.
9
The
excess
educational
investment
(over
and
above
what
middle
class
families
can
provide)
that
children
born
into
a
typical
one
percenter
household
receive
is
equivalent,
economically,
to
a
traditional
inheritance
of
between
5
and
10
million
dollars
per
child.
Exceptional
cases
always
exist—as
some
of
you
sitting
here
prove—but
in
general,
children
from
poor
or
even
middle
class
households
cannot
possibly
compete—when
they
apply
to
places
like
Yale—with
people
who
have
imbibed
this
massive,
sustained,
planned,
and
practiced
investment,
from
birth
or
even
in
the
womb.
And
workers
with
ordinary
training
cannot
possibly
compete—in
the
labor
market—with
super-‐skilled
workers
possessed
of
the
remarkable
training
that
places
like
Yale
Law
School
provide.
American
meritocracy
has
thus
become
precisely
what
it
was
invented
to
combat:
a
mechanism
for
the
dynastic
transmission
of
wealth
and
privilege
across
generations.
Meritocracy
now
constitutes
a
modern-‐day
aristocracy
,
one
might
even
say,
purpose-‐built
for
a
world
in
which
the
greatest
source
of
wealth
is
not
land
or
factories
but
human
capital,
the
free
labor
of
skilled
workers.
This
observation
re-‐focuses
the
argument
on
you—on
the
modern-‐day
aristocrats.
You
are
not—nor,
for
that
matter,
am
I—natural
objects
of
moral
or
political
sympathy.
Nevertheless,
this
system
does
not
serve
you
well,
either.
10
To
begin
with,
life
at
the
top
today
requires
immense
and
sustained
effort—extraordinarily
hard
work.
This,
also,
is
new.
In
1962,
the
American
Bar
Association
could
confidently
declare
that
“there
are
approximately
1300
fee
earning
hours
per
year”
available
to
the
normal
lawyer.
Today,
by
contrast,
a
major
law
firm
pronounces,
with
equal
confidence,
that
a
quota
of
2400
billable
hours
“if
properly
managed”
is
“not
unreasonable.”
Billing
2400
hours
requires
working
from
8
a.m.
until
8
p.m.,
six
days
a
week,
without
vacation
or
sick-‐days,
for
every
week
of
the
year.
Nor
are
these
Stakahnovite
hours
the
peculiar
property
of
large
private
practice.
Elite
public
interest
lawyers,
elite
government
lawyers,
and
even
elite
law
professors
all
work
hours
that
would
have
been
thought
unimaginable,
because
degrading,
by
an
earlier
American
elite
that
constituted
itself,
self-‐consciously,
as
a
leisure
class.
Embracing
long
hours
reflects
an
adjustment
to
a
new
economic
necessity.
A
rich
landowner
might
extract
rents
from
his
estate
idly,
as
a
rentier
.
But
where
the
source
of
a
person’s
wealth
is
her
human
capital—her
skills—she
cannot
get
income
except
by
mixing
this
capital
with
her
own
contemporaneous
labor.
Nevertheless,
these
hours—just
by
their
flat,
dispassionate,
unyielding
length—inflict
a
heavy
human
burden
on
those
who
work
them.
The
imaginative
requirements
of
living
as
a
super-‐ordinate
worker
impose
a
second
and
profound
burden
on
the
new
elite—a
11
burden
whose
full
weight
you
are
the
first
generation
to
feel.
The
social
and
economic
caste
order
in
which
we
are
embedded—including
through
our
celebrations
today—demands
that
you
comprehend
yourselves
on
instrumental
terms.
Your
own
talents,
training,
and
skills—your
self-‐same
persons—today
constitute
your
greatest
assets,
the
overwhelmingly
dominant
source
of
your
wealth
and
status.
To
promote
your
eliteness—to
secure
your
caste—you
must
ruthlessly
manage
your
training
and
labor.
Moreover,
(and
you’re
the
first
generation
in
this
position)
you’ve
had
to
do
this—to
act
as
asset-‐
managers
whose
portfolios
contain
yourselves
—for
your
whole
lives,
certainly
for
as
long
as
you
can
recall.
To
manage
an
asset
not
for
its
own
sake
but
rather
as
a
means
to
an
end
is
to
alienate
oneself
from
that
asset’s
true
nature
and
intrinsic
value.
The
older
rentier
-‐elite
might
administer
its
lands
and
factories
in
this
way
without
bearing
any
significant
cost.
But
administering
one’s
capacities—one’s
own
person—in
this
instrumental
mode
is
another
thing
entirely.
To
live
in
this
way
is,
quite
literally,
to
use
oneself
up
.
Such
a
life
proceeds
under
a
pervasive
shadow:
at
its
worst,
it
squanders
the
capacity
to
set
and
pursue
authentically
embraced,
intrinsically
valued,
goals;
even
at
its
best,
this
life
invites
deep
alienation.
Finally,
the
choices
that
you’ve
faced,
again
and
again
over
the
course
of
your
lives,
have
trained
you
to
measuring
your
life
in
this
way,
as
with
coffee-‐spoons.
It
can
seem,
with
warrant,
as
if
there
is
no
alternative
to
the
bright,
unreal
path
that
has
led
you
here.
12
Once
more,
the
elite
should
not—they
have
no
right
to—expect
sympathy
on
this
account
from
those
who
remain
excluded
from
the
privileges
and
benefits
of
high
caste.
And
yet,
the
human
burdens
of
life
as
rentier
of
one’s
own
human
capital
remain
real,
and
weighty.
I
believe,
from
our
many
conversations,
that
they
explain
why
you
approach
our
celebrations
in
a
contemplative
mood.
So
this
is
where
we’ve
arrived
today.
We’ve
constructed
a
gilded
cage
that
ensnares
the
rich
and
excludes
the
rest.
What,
then,
is
the
way
forward?
I
wish
that
I
knew.
I
could
tell
you—and
I
would
mean
it—that
when
you
find
an
opportunity
to
trade
a
little
money
or
status
for
a
lot
of
freedom,
you
should
take
it
.
.
.
you
should
take
it
every
time
.
But
that
thought—although
honest
and
heartfelt—is
a
chicanery,
akin
to
insisting
that
the
rat-‐race
is
over.
The
fact
remains
that,
for
each
of
you
individually,
all
the
forces
that
have
brought
you
to
this
point
remain
in
play.
Every
incentive
is
wrong.
But
the
broader
picture
is
more
hopeful.
The
new
aristocracy
promotes
human
flourishing
for
no
one
:
certainly
not
for
the
excluded
rest;
nor
even
for
the
ensnared
rich.
We
are
trained
to
think
of
economic
inequality
as
presenting
a
zero
sum
game:
to
suppose
that
redistribution
to
benefit
the
bottom
must
burden
the
top.
But
this
is
not
such
a
case:
reforms
that
democratize
training
and
talent
would
benefit
everybody
.
Such
democratic
reforms
would
restore
the
bulk
of
13
Americans
to
full
participation
in
an
economic
and
social
order
from
which
they
have
been,
for
several
decades
now,
increasingly
excluded.
And
democratic
reforms
invite
the
elite—you
all—to
accept
an
almost
costless
diminution
in
wealth
and
status
in
exchange
for
a
massive,
precious
increase
in
leisure
and
liberty,
a
reclaiming
of
your
authentic
selves.
The
problem
remains
how
to
make
the
global
trade,
how
to
re-‐
establish
a
democratic
social
order.
Again,
I
don’t
know.
But
I
do
know
that
a
winning
trade—winning
for
everyone—exists.
And
I
also
know
that
you—with
your
vast
talents,
enormous
discipline,
and
immense
energy—are
better-‐placed
than
anyone
else
to
conceive
and
to
broker
the
deal.
You
should
keep
a
reborn
democratic
equality
always
in
mind
as
you
go
forth,
in
your
small
decisions
as
well
as
your
large
ones.
You
should
support
and
sustain
one
another
whenever
you
chose
equality
and
freedom
over
caste
and
wealth.
And
you
should
demand
that
Yale
Law
School
loyally
supports
you
as
you
make
these
choices.
The
democratic
project
has
no
better
midwife;
and
so
much
turns
on
your
efforts
now;
including,
not
least
of
all,
your
own
futures.
Thank
you,
and
Godspeed.