Muhammad Yunus MIT Commencement Speech
Good Morning:
It as a very special privilege for me to speak at the commencement ceremony of this
prestigious institution.
What a wonderful feeling to be here today. To be with all of you, some of the
brightest minds in the world, right at a moment when you decide the path you will
embark on in life. You represent the future of the world. The choices that you will
make for yourself will decide the fate of mankind. This is how it has always been.
Sometimes we are aware of it, most of the time we are not. I hope you'll remain
aware of it and make an effort to be remembered not simply as a creative generation
but as a socially-conscious creative generation. Try it.
I had no idea whether my life would someday be relevant to anyone else's. But in the
mid-seventies, out of frustration with the terrible economic situation in Bangladesh I
decided to see if I could make myself useful to one poor person a day in the village
next door to the university campus where I was teaching. I found myself in an
unfamiliar situation. Out of necessity I had to find a way out. Since I did not have a
road-map, I had to fall back on my basic instinct to do that. At any moment I could
have withdrawn myself from my unknown path, but I did not. I stubbornly went on
to find my own way. Luckily, at the end, I found it. That was microcredit and
Grameen Bank.
Now, in hindsight, I can joke about it. When people ask me, "How did you figure out
all the rules and procedures that is now known as Grameen system ?" My answer is :
"That was very simple and easy. Whenever I needed a rule or a procedure in our
work, I just looked at the conventional banks to see what they do in a similar
situation. Once I learned what they did, I just did the opposite. That's how I got our
rules. Conventional banks go to the rich, we go to the poor; their rule is -- "the more
you have, the more you get." So our rule became -- "the less you have higher
attention you get. If you have nothing, you get the highest priority." They ask for
collateral, we abandoned it, as if we had never heard of it. They need lawyers in their
business, we don't. No lawyer is involved in any of our loan transactions. They are
owned by the rich, ours is owned by the poorest, the poorest women to boot. I can go
on adding more to this list to show how Grameen does things quite the opposite way.
Was it really a systematic policy æ to do it the opposite way ? No, it wasn't. But
that's how it turned out ultimately, because our objective was different. I had not
even noticed it until a senior banker admonished me by saying : Dr. Yunus, you are
trying to put the banking system upside down." I quickly agreed with him. I said :
"Yes, because the banking system is standing on its head."
I could not miss seeing the ruthlessness of moneylenders in the village. First I lent
the money to replace the loan-sharks. Then I went to the local bank to request them
to lend money to the poor. They refused.
After months of deadlock I persuaded them by offering myself as a guarantor. This is
how microcredit was born in 1976. Today Grameen Bank lends money to 7.5 million
borrowers, 97 per cent women. They own the bank. The bank has lent out over $ 7.0
billion in Bangladesh over the years. Globally 130 million poor families receive
microcredit. Even then banks have not changed much. They do not mind writing off
a trillion dollars in a sub-prime crisis, but they still stay away from lending US $ 100
to a poor woman despite the fact such loans have near 100 per cent repayment
record globally.
While focusing on microcredit we saw the need for other types of interventions to
help the rural population, in general, and the poor, in particular. We tried our
interventions in the health sector, information technology, renewable energy and on
several other fronts.
Since we worked with poor women, health issue quickly drew our attention. We
introduced health insurance. We succeeded in developing an effective healthcare
program based on health insurance, but have not been able to expand this program
because of non-availability of doctors. Doctors are reluctant to stay in the villages. (It
has become such a big bottleneck that we have now decided to set up a medical
college to produce doctors.) Under the program a villager pays about US $ 2.00 a
year as health insurance premium, to get health coverage for the entire family.
Financially it is sustainable.
I became a strong believer in the power of information technology to change the lives
of the poor people. This encouraged me to create a cell-phone company called
Grameen Phone. We brought phones to the villages of Bangladesh and gave loans to
the poor women to buy themselves cell-phones to sell their service and make money.
It became an instant success.
Seventy percent of the population of Bangladesh do not have access to electricity. We
wanted to address this issue by introducing solar home system in the villages. We
created a separate company called Grameen Shakti, or Grameen Energy. It became a
very successful company in popularising solar home system, bio-gas, and
environment-friendly cooking stoves. It has already reached 155,000 homes with
solar home systems, and aims to reach one million homes by 2012. As we started
creating a series of companies around renewable energy, information technology,
textile, agriculture, livestock, education, health, finance etc, I was wondering why
conventional businesses do not see business the way we see it. They have different
goals than ours. We design our businesses one way, they design theirs in another
way.
Conventional businesses are based on the theoretical framework provided by the
designers of capitalist economic system. In this framework 'business' has to be a
profit-maximizing entity. The more aggressively a business pursues it, the better the
system functions æ we are told. The bigger the profit, the more successful the
business is; the more happy investors are. In my work it never occurred to me that I
should maximize profit. All my struggle was to take each of my enterprises to a level
where it could at least be self-sustaining. I defined the mission of my businesses in a
different way than that of the traditional businesses.
As I was doing it, obviously I was violating the basic tenet of capitalist system æ
profit maximization. Since I was engaged in finding my own solution to reach the
mission of my business, I was not looking at any existing road maps. My only
concern was to see if my path was taking me where I wanted to go. When it worked I
felt very happy. I know maximization of profit makes people happy. I don't maximize
profit, but my businesses are a great source of my happiness. If you had done what I
have done you would be very happy too! I am convinced that profit maximization is
not the only source of happiness in business. 'Business' has been interpreted too
narrowly in the existing framework of capitalism. This interpretation is based on the
assumption that a human being is a single dimensional being. His business-related
happiness is related to the size of the profit he makes. He is presented as a robot-like
money-making machine.
But we all know that real-life human beings are multi-dimensional beings æ not
uni-dimensional like the theory assumes. For a real-life human being money-making
is a means, not an end. But for the businessman in the existing theory
money-making is both a means and also an end.
This narrow interpretation has done us great damage. All business people around the
world have been imitating this one-dimensional theoretical businessman as precisely
as they can to make sure they get the most from the capitalist system. If you are a
businessman you have to wear profit-maximizing glasses all the time. As a result,
only thing you see in the world are the profit enhancing opportunities. Important
problems that we face in the world cannot be addressed because profit-maximizing
eyes cannot see them.
We can easily reformulate the concept of a businessman to bring him closer to a real
human being. In order to take into account the multi-dimensionality of real human
being we may assume that there are two distinct sources of happiness in the business
world æ 1) maximizing profit, and 2) achieving some pre-defined social objective.
Since there are clear conflicts between the two objectives, the business world will
have to be made up of two different kinds of businesses --1) profit-maximizing
business, and 2) social business. Specific type of happiness will come from the
specific type of business.
Then an investor will have two choices æ he can invest in one or in both. My guess is
most people will invest in both in various proportions. This means people will use
two sets of eye-glassesæ profit-maximizing glasses, and social business glasses. This
will bring a big change in the world. Profit maximizing businessmen will be amazed
to see how different the world looks once they take off the profit-maximizing glasses
and wear the social business glasses. By looking at the world from two different
perspectives business decision-makers will be able to decide better, act better, and
these decisions and actions will lead to a dramatically better world.
While I was wondering whether the idea of social business would make any sense to
the corporate world I had an opportunity to talk to the chairman of Danone Group
Mr. Franck Riboud about this subject. It made perfect sense to him right away.
Together we created Grameen Danone company as a social business in Bangladesh.
This company produces yogurt fortified with micro-nutrients which are missing in
the mal-nourished children of Bangladesh. Because it is a social business, Grameen
and Danone, will never take any dividend out of the company beyond recouping the
initial investment. Bottom line for the company is to see how many children
overcome their nutrition deficiency each year.
Next initiative came from Credit Agricole of France. We created Grameen Credit
Agricole Microfinance Foundation to provide financial support to microfinance
organizations and social businesses.
We created a small water company to provide good quality drinking water in a
cluster of villages of Bangladesh. This is a joint venture with Veolia, a leading water
company in the world. Bangladesh has terrible drinking water problem. In a large
part of Bangladesh tubewell water is highly arsenic contaminated, surface water is
polluted. This social business water company will be a prototype for supplying safe
drinking water in a sustainable and affordable way to people who are faced with
water crisis. Once it is perfected, it can be replicated in other villages, within
Bangladesh and outside.
We have already established an eye-care hospital specializing in cataract operation,
with a capacity to undertake 10,000 operations per year. This is a joint venture social
business with the Green Children Foundation created by two singers in their early
twenties, Tom and Milla, from England and Norway.
We have signed a joint-venture agreement with Intel Corporation, to create a social
business company called Grameen-Intel to bring information technology-based
services to the poor in healthcare, marketing, education and remittances.
We also signed a social business joint venture agreement with Saudi German
Hospital Group to set up a series of hospitals in Bangladesh.
Many more companies from around the world are showing interest in such social
business joint ventures. A leading shoe company wants to create a social business to
make sure that nobody goes without shoes. One leading pharmaceutical company
wishes to set up a joint venture social business company to produce nutritional
supplements appropriate for Bangladeshi pregnant mothers and young women, at
the cheapest possible price.
We are also in discussion to launch a social business company to produce chemically
treated mosquito-nets to protect people in Bangladesh and Africa from malaria and
other mosquito-borne diseases.
Your generation can bring a breakthrough in changing the course of the world. You
can be the socially-conscious creative generation that the world is waiting for. You
can bring your creativity to design brilliant social businesses to overcome poverty,
disease, environmental degradation, food crisis, depletion of non-renewable
resources, etc. Each one of you is capable of changing the world. To make a start all
that each one of you has to do is to design a business plan for a social business. Each
prototype of a social business can be a cute little business. But if it works out, the
whole world can be changed by replicating it in thousands of locations.
Prototype development is the key. In designing a prototype all we need is a
socially-oriented creative mind. That could be each one of you. No matter what you
do in your life, make it a point to design or be involved with at least one social
business to address one problem that depresses you the most. If you have the design
and the money, go ahead and put it into action. If you have the design but no money,
contact your dean -- he will find the money. I never heard that MIT has problem in
finding money when it has a hot idea in its hand. MIT can even create a social
business development fund in anticipation of your requests.
I can tell you very emphatically that in terms of human capability there is no
difference between a poor person and a very privileged person. All human beings are
packed with unlimited potential. Poor people are no exception to this rule. But the
world around them never gave them the opportunity to know that each of them is
carrying a wonderful gift in them. The gift remains unknown and unwrapped. Our
challenge is to help the poor unwrap their gift.
Poverty is not created by the poor. It is created by the system. Poverty is an artificial
imposition on people. Once you fall outside the system, it works against you. It
makes it very difficult to return to the system.
How do we change this? Where do we begin ?
Three basic interventions will make a big difference in the existing system : a)
broadening the concept of business by including "social business" into the
framework of market place, b) creating inclusive financial and healthcare services
which can reach out to every person on the planet, c) designing appropriate
information technology devices, and services for the bottom-most people and
making them easily available to them.
Your generation has the opportunity to make a break with the past and create a
beautiful new world. We see the ever-growing problems created by the
individual-centered aggressively accumulative economy. If we let it proceed without
serious modifications, we may soon reach the point of no return. Among other
things, this type of economy has placed our planet under serious threat through
climatic distortions. Single-minded pursuit of profit has made us forget that this
planet is our home; that we are supposed to make it safe and beautiful, not make it
more unliveable everyday by promoting a life-style which ignores all warnings of
safety.
At this point let me give you the good news. No matter how daunting the problems
look, don't get brow beaten by their size. Big problems are most often just an
aggregation of tiny problems. Get to the smallest component of the problem. Then it
becomes an innocent bite-size problem, and you can have all the fun dealing with it.
You'll be thrilled to see in how many ways you can crack it. You can tame it or make
it disappear by various social and economic actions, including social business. Pick
out the action which looks most efficient in the given circumstances. Tackling big
problems does not always have to be through giant actions, or global initiatives or
big businesses. It can start as a tiny little action. If you shape it the right way, it can
grow into a global action in no time. Even the biggest problem can be cracked by a
small well-designed intervention. That's where you and your creativity come in.
These interventions can be so small that each one of you can crack these problems
right from your garage. If you have a friend or two to work with you, it is all the more
better. It can be fun too.
You are born in the age of ideas. Ideas are something an MIT graduate, I am sure,
will not run out of. The question I am raising now -- what use you want to make of
them ? Make money by selling or using your ideas ? Or change the world with your
ideas? Or do both ? It is upto you to decide.
There are two clear tasks in front of you -- 1) to end poverty in the world once for all,
and 2) to set the world in the right path to undo all the damage we have done to the
environment by our ignorance and selfishness. Time is right. Your initiatives can
produce big results, even lead you to achieving these goals. Then yours will be the
most successful generation in human history. You will take your grand-children to
the poverty museums with tremendous pride that your generation had finally made
it happen.
Congratulations, for being part of a generation which has exciting possibilities, and
advance congratulations to you all for your future successes in creating a new world
where everyone on this planet can stand tall as a human being.
Thank you.